A critique of sweetness and power by sidney mintz

Althusser, L and E. Now organic food can seem like little more than window dressing for elite shoppers. Sid taught Intro when he was an assistant professor, at mid-career, and after he had reached the super-distinguished heights.

French Marxist anthropology enjoyed cult status during the s. In fact, I lived for a time in utter denial that I would ever have to seriously reckon with it again.

Alas, if we take a few steps beyond Boston, we find a very different common knowledge. But in the meantime, economics was rapidly remaking itself as a positive science.

To obtain slaves, products were shipped to Africa. The phenomenology of the human subject, the dialectic and indeed history itself were in effect dropped from their scheme. Current Anthropology 41 2: Gerd Spittler this volume, forthcoming approaches these early contributions through a focus on work: It blew apart the myopic, sanitized histories of my own past, my own community.

It is by no means clear whether the word is primarily subjective or objective. Factory, Family and Neighbourhood: The absolute dominance of market logic, at least in the form devised by neo-liberal economists, may be coming to an end. In this way, sugar as a dietary staple of the proletariat, was a propeller of labor force output and productivity.

It is not evident that they were married in the first place. The last two chapters are problematic, IMO - far too much space has been devoted to theory, defending the earlier historical materialist approach against disciplinary battles with social anthropology, while the prior historical approach is ultimately jettisoned in favour of abstract speculation about contemporary food As a commodity history this is somewhat dated, and as other GR reviewers have noted, in need of tighter editing, both stylistically and structurally.

Although a slim volume, it manages to document the connections between a dizzying number of social facts, uniting them to a common theoretical framework.

Despite our focus on historical change, there are some abiding questions at the intersection of economics and anthropology. It makes sense to me that we should be unearthing the remains of the New Deal in our scholarly apparatus.

Sidney Mintz

Culture, Society and Economy: He died on December 26, at the age of 94, following severe head trauma resulting from a fall. The legitimacy of Melanesian currencies. But these histories--the stories of these unknown people--may as well have been from another part of the world.

They were more than a match for the neo-classical economists there in the interwar period Yonay For Aristotle and thinkers like him, it had nothing to do with markets or money or with wider notions of society.

The growth of demand for sugar was a machination of those in power Mintz I have also finally realized that Mintz—and by extension, Sweetness and Power—was himself a product of the history I describe in Sugar and Civilization, which covers the period between the Spanish American War and the end of the New Deal.

This formulation forecloses analysis of a crucial circuit of power—the fuzzy slippage between the category of producer and consumer when production and consumption take place in precisely the same location. Maurice Godelier, too, has proved that there is life after Marxism by continuing to produce significant work, notably The Enigma of the Gift and a review of economic anthropology I would look at each textbook and evaluate them on two items: The Guest textbook sounds like an ideal way to introduce these issues, especially for a Cultural Anthropology course.

Primitive Economics of the New Zealand Maori. Jan 03,  · Review of Sweetness and Power. In Theory and Society 16(4) Marino, John A. Review of Sweetness and Power. In The Journal of Modern History 59(3) Mintz, Sidney W.

Sweetness and Power. United States: Viking Penguin Inc. Roxborough, Ian Review of Sweetness and Power. In Man 21(3) Ross, Clark G. Sidney Mintz’s Long, Sweet Legacy 0. By April Merleaux on June 23, five rereadings, and a book of my own, I am finally ready to venture a critique of Sweetness and Power.

Mintz, as I now read him, overdrew the distinction between production and consumption. The irony is that I could never have understood these limits without Mintz.

Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar in Modern History

Sidney Mintz's "Sweetness and Power" is a global history by an anthropologist, so lay readers may find parts of it a little hard to get into, and even historians may /5.

Port Manteaux churns out silly new words when you feed it an idea or two. Enter a word (or two) above and you'll get back a bunch of portmanteaux created by jamming together words that are conceptually related to your inputs. For example, enter "giraffe" and you'll get.

My work on sugar, Sweetness and Power, situates it within Western history because it was an old commodity, basic to the emergence of a global market. The first time I was in the field I'd been surrounded by it, as I did my fieldwork. Unlike most editing & proofreading services, we edit for everything: grammar, spelling, punctuation, idea flow, sentence structure, & more.

Get started now!

A critique of sweetness and power by sidney mintz
Rated 5/5 based on 5 review
Sweet Talking: A Review of Sidney Mintz’s Sweetness and Power | The Tiger Manifesto